Luke Barnes, Western Sydney University

This is an article from I’ve Always Wondered, a series where readers send in questions they’d like an expert to answer. Send your question to alwayswondered@theconversation.edu.au


If you’re in a falling elevator, can you really save yourself by jumping off the floor at the last second? – Rosanna, Perth

It’s a nightmarish scenario – the elevator seals you inside, rises several floors, judders to a halt, and then SNAP! The frayed cable fails, and you plummet. Can you save yourself by jumping at the right time?

Falling’s not a problem, when I’m falling I’m at peace.

It’s only when I hit the ground that causes all the grief

(Florence + The Machine)



Read more:
I’ve always wondered: why do we get dark circles under our eyes?


In this predicament, the key point to realise is that along with the elevator, you are also falling. When the floor of the elevator makes a sudden stop due to hitting the base of the lift shaft, you too will make a sudden stop.

If you jump, will it help? Let’s attach a camera to the elevator, so that it falls with you, and watch the crucial final moments in slow motion.

You jump at just the right moment, and lift off just as the elevator hits the floor. At this moment, you are (to our camera) moving upwards with what we will call your jump speed. At this crucial moment, just before it hits the ground, the elevator is falling with a certain elevator speed.

Because of your leap, you are falling more slowly than the elevator. The speed at which you hit the floor of the (suddenly stopped) elevator is the elevator speed minus your jump speed.

How good is your jump?
Jared Sluyter/unsplash

It depends how far you fall

As an equivalent, we can think in terms of height: how high was the elevator when it fell, and how high can you jump?

Let’s be optimistic, and say that you’re a an NBA player with a vertical leap of 70cm. We’ll run through a few scenarios (more information on how I made the calculations is shown as a footnote).

Falling one storey (3m): timed right, you hit the ground as if you fell from 80cm. Dust yourself off; you’ll be fine. You’ll only have 0.8 seconds to react, however, so be prepared!

Falling three storeys (9m): you hit the ground as if you fell 4.7m. Your predicament is upgraded from possibly dead to alive but injured. Expect a broken leg or two, but you’ll live.

(Some have suggested lying down in the lift, because it will distribute the force of impact over your whole body. This is a terrible idea – protect your brain! Some part of your body must absorb the impact, but head injury is the primary cause of death in falls. Let your legs take the hit.)

Falling five storeys (15m): you hit the ground as if you fell 9 metres, which is the difference between probably dead and probably alive. This is the crucial case, the difference between life and death. You’ll have 1.7 seconds to react. Good luck.

Falling seven storeys (21m): it’s as if you fell 14m. Sorry, but you’ve probably got about 2 seconds to prepare to meet your maker.



Read more:
Curious Kids: Why aren’t birds pulled down by gravity while they’re flying?


Some assumptions – for science

I’ve made some simplifying assumptions. I assumed that your timing is perfect, despite probably being unable to see the ground. This Mythbusters episode showed that this is very difficult. A moment too late, you’ve already hit the floor; a moment too soon, and you might hit your head on the ceiling of the elevator and lose your jump speed.

I assume that you are able to effectively push off the floor as you jump, which is challenging because gravity is pulling the floor of the elevator away from you. If you are suddenly in free fall, you will need to grab a hand rail to keep contact with the floor.

I’ve assumed that you hit a solid floor at the bottom of the shaft, but people have survived falling elevators due to the cable below coiling in the shaft, softening the impact. (Others have been crushed when the enormous broken cable above landed on the top of the elevator.)



Read more:
I’ve always wondered: why do our computing devices seem to slow down?


Air resistance makes little difference – the elevator will be falling at over 200 km/h before any noticeable drag kicks in.

However, air can save you in another way. Trapped air in the shaft below the elevator may provide an additional cushion. Suppose we drop the elevator from 7 storeys again. If the shaft were perfectly sealed like a piston, the elevator would only drop 50cm before the extra pressure of the compressed air supported its weight.

But there is usually a gap between the shaft and the elevator, which allows the cushion to deflate. If this happens faster than the elevator can pressurise the air, or if the pressure blows the lower doors open, then you’ll still fall rather quickly.

A “back-of-the-envelope” calculation suggests that, to effectively trap the air, the gap between the elevator and the (air-tight) shaft needs to be thinner than about 30-50cm.

Go ahead and jump

In conclusion, don’t worry. Modern elevators have a wide variety of safety backups, such as multiple cables and electromagnetic brakes. But if the worst should happen, take Van Halen’s advice: you might as well jump!

Go ahead!

The ConversationNotes on my calculations: Impact speed = elevator speed – jump speed. Then, we can relate speeds to equivalent heights, using some Newtonian mechanics: speed = √(2 × g × height), where g is acceleration due to gravity. Substitute and solve for equivalent height of fall.

Luke Barnes, Postdoctoral research fellow, Western Sydney University

This article was originally published on The Conversation. Read the original article.

There are no comments yet.

Leave a Reply